Lawyer tells British Supreme Court Northern Ireland women are “second class citizens” because NHS won’t fund their abortions

Editor’s note. This comes from our friends at SPUC–the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children.

unbornbaby9-10-wks1The Supreme Court heard yesterday that Northern Irish women are “second class citizens” on abortion. This claim was made by Stephen Cragg, who is representing two women who want women from Northern Ireland to be allowed access to National Health Service-funded abortions in England.

The mother and daughter, identified only as A and B, travelled to England for the girl to have an abortion when she was 15.

Responding for the government, Jason Coppel said it was not irrational for the provision of non-emergency healthcare to be divided between the different countries of the United Kingdom, according to the place of residence of the patient.

Last year the Court of Appeal ruled that there is no legal obligation on health services in England and Wales to provide publicly funded abortions which would be unlawful within Northern Ireland. However they were granted permission to appeal to the British Supreme Court

The Supreme Court granted six pro-abortion organizations the right to intervene in the case: Alliance for Choice, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, Birthrights, the Family Planning Association, Abortion Support Network and the British Humanist Association have been granted permission to provide their perspectives on the case.

Constitutional attack on Northern Ireland’s devolved institutions

“This case amounts to a constitutional attack on Northern Ireland’s devolved institutions, an attack on the rule of law, and a wholesale assault on the human rights of unborn children,” said Liam Gibson, SPUC’s Northern Ireland Development Officer.

“Lawyers for the Secretary of State for Health have rightly pointed out that abortion is illegal in Northern Ireland. It is an affront to Northern Ireland’s constitutional structures to try to bypass its democratic decision not to allow abortion. Taking children abroad to be destroyed because they are protected in their home region shows contempt for the rule of law. And the failure of courts to recognize the facts of human life before birth is a ruse to evade the moral imperative to uphold basic human rights.”

Unborn babies not counted as persons

Gibson continued, “It is deplorable to hear clever lawyers perpetuating the fiction that babies in the womb are not real. They are real. They suffer and bleed and die. But our legal system is a shadow-land where unborn babies don’t count as persons. They grow, respond and learn while in the womb, but they are routinely killed because judges shut their eyes to reality.”

No human right to abortion

Gibson concluded, “The presiding judge in this case, Lady Brenda Hale, has expressed her support for women’s rights. We support women’s rights, too, but not at the expense of the lives of others.

“There is no basis in human rights for a right to abortion. There is, however, an internationally recognized right to life for everyone, and Northern Ireland seeks to respect that. There is also an obligation on the court not simply to uphold the law, but to act justly. Contrary to the pro-abortion groups that want more public funding for abortion, it is not Northern Irish women who are ‘second class citizens’ when it comes to abortion, but the unborn children in the rest of the UK. They are second class citizens who can be stripped of their legal protection, killed in the womb with impunity, and treated with contempt by the court.”