By Michael Cook
A former chair of the Danish Council of Ethics has published a broadside on legalised euthanasia in The BMJ . Ole Hartling, a doctor, author and co-author of several books, was a member of the Council between 2000 and 2007 and its chair for five years. During that time, the Council carried on extensive debates on end-of-life issues. In 2006 the Council “disrecommended” euthanasia.
His focus in The BMJ is on the illusion of autonomy. Euthanasia is often described as the ultimate expression of autonomy but Hartling is deeply sceptical. He recently published a book (in English) on the topic: Euthanasia and the Ethics of a Doctor’s Decisions: An Argument Against Assisted Dying, published by Bloomsbury. He stresses in this book that he does not rely upon “sanctity of life” arguments. “These lines of thought are metaphysical and easily become dogmatic and hence unconvincing,” he writes. His arguments are secular and aim to show that legalisation is simply untenable.
In his essay in The BMJ, Hartling writes:
Decisions about your own death are not made in normal day-to-day contexts. The wish to die arises against a backdrop: of desperation, a feeling of hopelessness, possibly a feeling of being superfluous. Otherwise, the wish would not be there. Thus, it is under these circumstances that the right to self-determination is exercised and the decision is made. Such a situation is a fragile basis for autonomy and an even more fragile basis for decision making. The choice regarding your own death is therefore completely different from most other choices usually associated with the concept of autonomy.
The essay is thought-provoking and well-worth reading.
Michael Cook is editor of BioEdge where this appeared. Reposted with permission.
By Dave Andrusko A divided three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit sided with attorneys for… Read More
Part Three: No Matter What Happens with the Law, Still Abortion By Randall K. O’Bannon,… Read More
By Dave Andrusko The size of the shift is incredible, but Gallup told us yesterday… Read More
By Karen Cross, National Right to Life Political Director Editor’s note. This appeared in the… Read More
By Dave Andrusko Pro-life champion Chris Smith (R-NJ) gave an exclusive interview to Dr. Susan… Read More