“Yes, I suspected that I was not alone”: More about Men and Abortion

By Mark Pickup

Editor’s note. Father’s Day is this Sunday. For many men who have been a party to an abortion, this will be a grim reminder of obligations shirked and lives lost. The following ran April 24, 2012.

Mark Pickup

Mark Pickup

As I mentioned in a previous blog post called “Men and Abortion,” I gave a short address to a meeting of the Knights of Columbus in Edmonton (Canada). I spoke about them sponsoring a conference to help men affected by abortion. It cuts fairly close to home for me. I am one of those men. In 1971, my girlfriend became pregnant with our baby. I pressured her to have an abortion; eventually she succumbed to the pressure and aborted our baby. For decades I regretted my role in that abortion.

Throughout the years, feminists have emphatically maintained that abortion is a “women’s issue” that does not affect men. They must be wrong! If they were right then why did my heart ache so? If abortion does not affect men then why did my conscience condemn me for so many years? Of course the view that abortion does not affect men was/is the product of twisted feminism and the misandrists who have populated their ranks.

Was I the only man haunted by the dreams, the irrational sense of a foreshortened future, the sadness at lost fatherhood, the nagging desire to make things right and atone for my role in the abortion? Every time I would meet someone who was born in 1972, I would think of my son or daughter. I suspected that I was not alone in my regrets.

Social custom expects men affected by post-abortion grief to be silent. Men affected by abortion have been marginalized and separated from discussions that recognized the post-abortion grief. Disclosure or help-seeking was unlikely.

For too long our grief has been discounted by mainstream scholarly discourse, media and establishment elites. But my grief was real regardless of conventional wisdom maintaining otherwise.

Yes, I suspected that I was not alone.

Then in 2007 I read an article in the Knights of Columbus magazine Columbia about a conference sponsored by the Knights in San Francisco for men of abortion. The conference was called “RECLAIMING FATHERHOOD: A multifaceted Examination of Men Dealing with Abortion.”

I thought, “At last! There is an awareness surfacing of post-abortion syndrome in men. Our sorrow at lost fatherhood has been recognized thanks to the Knights of Columbus!”

Dr. Vincent M. Rue is a physiotherapist with more than thirty years experience treating post-abortion trauma. He is an expert in this field and was one of the speakers at the conference. Although Dr. Rue states that post-abortion grief transcends genders, in a later interview with Columbia he said that there are factors specific to helping men resolve emotional pain of abortion.

He recognizes that men are at a disadvantage because, as he said, “men must overcome cultural and psychological hang-ups about communicating feelings. … Men need safe places to talk about their issues.”

Apparently another conference was held in 2009 in Chicago for psychologists, counselors, clergy, academics and ordinary men and women who have experienced abortion. According to another Knights of Columbus article, they “spoke out about what they say is an “invisible problem” — men, as well as women, can have profound grief and suffering as a result of abortion.”

It is time for men who have suffered from post-abortion syndrome to be allowed to address their grief and move toward healing in this area of their lives. At a personal level, I found healing through a long and difficult spiritual journey that culminated in being forgiven by God, through His Son Jesus Christ. I laid my lost fatherhood of forty years ago at the foot of the cross. It was only then that I was able to truly forgive myself.

It know many brutish men have no remorse for their children killed by abortion. I am not talking about them. I am talking about men who suffer post-abortion trauma and grieve lost fatherhood. It is time their grief be recognized, not dismissed, and avenues made available for them to settle that grief within the context of community.

I encourage more conferences like what happened in San Francisco and Chicago.