Categories: JudicialLegislation

US Court of Appeals gives Texas an Historic Pro-Life Victory Again

 

By Texas Right to Life

A panel of three judges in the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit released its ruling upholding HB2, Texas’ Pro-Life law, which took full effect in October of last year. The opinion affirms the constitutionality of the legislation passed last summer and rejects Planned Parenthood’s argument that HB2 places an “undue burden” upon abortionists, abortion facilities, and women seeking abortion.

The court upheld sections of the law that require abortionists hold admitting privileges at a nearby hospital, and that the dangerous RU-486 abortion drug be administered according to FDA procedure. The judges wrote,

“The district court held that parts of both provisions were unconstitutional and granted, in substantial part, the requested injunctive relief. A motions panel of this court granted a stay pending appeal, and the Supreme Court upheld the stay. We conclude that both of the challenged provisions are constitutional and, therefore, reverse and render judgment, with one exception, for the State.”

The court asserted that higher standards for an abortionist are, in fact, justified,

“During these proceedings, Planned Parenthood conceded that at least 210 women in Texas annually must be hospitalized after seeking an abortion. Witnesses on both sides further testified that some of the women who are hospitalized after an abortion have complications that require an Ob/Gyn specialist’s treatment.”

This is the third time recently that this Court of Appeals has upheld Pro-Life policies attacked by abortion advocates. The same court upheld Texas’ 2011 Sonogram Law and a policy that kept the abortion business Planned Parenthood out of the taxpayer-funded Women’s Health Program.

The decision on House Bill 2 has been expected ever since the New Orleans hearing in January where the three-judge panel heard Planned Parenthood’s attempts to convince them that such measures provide an undue burden to women seeking abortion. However, these claims made in court apparently had little effect on the judges, who seem to be unimpressed with the exaggerated nature of the lawsuit and that Planned Parenthood requested the Supreme Court’s precedent establishing the meaning of “undue burden” be overlooked by the Fifth Circuit Court.

Planned Parenthood may have jumped the gun in making such broad and overarching undue burden arguments. The 5th Circuit justices wrote in their opinion; Planned Parenthood’s case required evidence that could only be provided after the law has been sufficiently applied. Namely, Planned Parenthood would have to present the court with a sufficient number of documented cases in which the provisions of HB2 caused a severe impediment to a woman seeking an abortion.

Texas Right to Life celebrates the 5th Circuit’s conscientious decision that upholds the protections and safeguards afforded by HB2 .

Recent Posts

New polls show that minority of British public support abortion being available to 20 weeks

By Right to Life UK According to the latest polling, while 65% of the population… Read More

22 mins ago

Idaho Supreme Court rejects challenge, rules abortion ban can begin on August 25

By Dave Andrusko Late Friday the Idaho Supreme Court ruled that the state’s comprehensive ban… Read More

25 mins ago

Ethical perils lie ahead after the creation of ‘synthetic embryos’

Israeli scientists have succeeded in creating and growing mice embryos outside a womb By Michael Cook… Read More

29 mins ago

‘Disturbing’: Experts troubled by Canada’s euthanasia laws which arguably are the world’s most permissive

By Alex Schadenberg, Executive Director, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition Maria Cheng published an investigative report for… Read More

1 hour ago

Philadelphia dumps $500,000 into abortion fund for poor women

By Bridget Sielicki Philadelphia Mayor Jim Kenney has announced that the city sent $500,000 to… Read More

1 hour ago

Survey of post-abortive women shows their emotional trauma

By Sarah Terzo The pro-life group Heartbeats conducted a survey of post-abortive women. They asked… Read More

1 hour ago