Categories: Conscience Laws

Lawyer for Pro-Life New Jersey nurses challenges idea that accommodations have been made to meet their objections to participating in abortions

By Dave Andrusko

U.S. Rep. Chris Smith

One thing you need to remember: when pro-life health personnel are discriminated against, you will first be told it ain’t so and then told it’s been remedied even though there was nothing wrong in the first place.

I apologize for missing the latest twist in the story of the twelve pro-life New Jersey nurses which took place last Friday. First, a couple of words of background.

For reasons the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey chooses not to reveal, UMDNJ abruptly changed its policy from allowing nurses to honor their consciences and NOT participate in abortions to threatening them with the loss of their job if they didn’t.

Assisted by the Alliance Defense Fund (ADF), the nurses took the hospital to court where on November 3, and a federal judge granted a temporary restraining order stopping all training, procedures and performances related to abortions for the suing nurses.

UMDNJ  adamantly insisted it is in violation of no state or federal law, when it clearly is. It defended this conclusion by arguing that it is demanding only that nurses “perform peripheral duties for abortion patients”—such as “logging information, drawing blood,” etc.

In an editorial supporting the nurses, the New Jersey Star-Ledger observed,

“In other words, UMDNJ believes it should be able to compel nurses and other health care professionals, against their moral beliefs, to perform duties leading all the way up to the actual abortion, then force those health care professionals to attend to patients immediately afterward — or lose their jobs.

“Narrowing the law to specify that nurses have the right to opt out of   only the actual abortion procedure strains common sense.”

But it turns out that last Friday—at the same time UMDNJ is insisting “Its position will be vindicated when the court gives this matter a full hearing” because “The university is in full compliance with all applicable state and federal laws”–it issued a statement saying it would “hire additional staff to help perform abortions,” according to a story that ran in the Star-Ledger.

This hospital statement “indicates a policy shift from the university’s initial stance,” according to David Giambusso. True? Interestingly, when his story appeared elsewhere, a paragraph was conveniently omitted challenging that optimistic conclusion.

“’The hospital filed a brief last week asking the court’s permission to continue bullying nurses into participating in elective abortion cases,” [ADF] lawyer Matt Bowman said in an e-mail. “Only by guaranteeing the court and the nurses that it has reversed its position would it prove that UMDNJ might finally be interested in following the law. Until then, ADF will continue to fight the illegal discrimination against these pro-life nurses.”

I’ve been unable to get a hold of Mr. Bowman to find out exactly what was in the hospital’s  brief. Stay tuned.

Your feedback is very important to improving National Right to Life News Today. Please send your comments to daveandrusko@gmail.com. If you like, join those who are following me on Twitter at http://twitter.com/daveha

Share

Recent Posts

Virtual pregnancy help tool is a vital resource

“She said she just had a baby and could not have another,” Harris said. The… Read More

14 hours ago

What every Pro-Life supporter can do and is a tremendous help to National Right to Life and our state affiliates

By Laura Echevarria, Director of Communications and Press Secretary Editor’s note. This appeared in the… Read More

14 hours ago

A deeper look at NRLC’s “The State of Abortion in the United States—10th edition”

By Dave Andrusko On Monday National Right to Life unveiled its 10th annual “The State of Abortion… Read More

14 hours ago

National Right to Life Praises Pro-life House and Senate Leaders for Supporting the Right to Life

Pro-life Leaders Offer a Sharp Contrast to the White House and Vice President Kamala Harris… Read More

14 hours ago

Showdown looms between States and Biden administration over “medication abortion”

By Dave Andrusko On Wednesday, GenBioPro, one of company that makes mifepristone, the first of… Read More

14 hours ago

The ‘Pregnancy Tissue’ Deflection

By Wesley J. Smith The last thing that abortion-rights activists want is an accurate description of… Read More

19 hours ago