By Randall K. O'Bannon, Ph.D.
Education is a lot like gardening. You pull the weeds, till the
soil, plant the seeds, and watch for bugs. And you wait. You don’t
get your flowers or vegetables for weeks, or even months. But there
is no harvest unless you do that tough work months ahead of time.
We’ve seen some very, very encouraging signs of that in 2011.
Overall, of course, we’ve seen the drop in abortions and abortion
rates in roughly the past 20 or 30 years—from 1.6 million lost lives
in 1990 and a rate of close to 30 abortions per 1,000 women of
reproductive age in 1980 to about 1.2 million abortions today and a
rate under 20 per 1,000. (This comes from figures produced by the
Guttmacher Institute for 2008.)
Pregnant women are more likely to choose life for their unborn
babies today than at any time since those first years after Roe.
This means that there are already millions of children alive today
than would have been if trends had stayed the same.
Polls show public attitudes are more pro-life than they have been
for years, and that young people are especially sympathetic to the
pro-life view. We may have a ways to go to reach the point where the
public is ready to restore full protection to the unborn, but we
have made serious progress.
What has made such a difference? It seems clear that concentrated
pro-life educational efforts over the past several years have led to
a more widespread knowledge of fetal development and a greater
understanding of abortion’s risks as well as life-affirming
alternatives.
For years, we have quite accurately told people that Planned
Parenthood is the nation’s largest abortion performer and promoter,
not just some benign provider of “reproductive health care” for poor
women. And for years, local, state, and federal government officials
kept sending millions Planned Parenthood’s way.
We have not only told people of Planned Parenthood’s abortion
connections, but detailed how the group has increased and expanded
its abortion business. The chain is now responsible for more than a
quarter of all U.S. abortions performed every year.
We have, in factsheets and articles, showed how the 332,278
abortions performed in Planned Parenthood clinics in 2009
translated, at current rates, to at least $149.9 million in
revenues—more than a third of PPFA’s clinic revenues. The real
number is likely to be considerably more, as Planned Parenthood
clinics advertise and perform more expensive chemical and later
surgical abortions.
We have shown how the organization that likes to associate itself
with “choice” actually offers few real practical choices to pregnant
women. PPFA delivers prenatal care services to fewer than 4% of
those patients and abortions outnumber adoptions at Planned
Parenthood by a margin of 340 to 1.
For the longest time, Planned Parenthood spokespersons simply
passed this off with a rhetorical wave of the hand, saying that
abortion accounted for only 3% of its total services. The National
Right to Life Educational Trust Fund challenged that claim. Our
research, using Planned Parenthood’s own figures, revealed how
essential abortion was to its financial bottom line. Abortion not
only accounts directly for a third or more of PPFA’s total clinic
revenues, but it is connected also to many ancillary services sold
to women.
For several years, the Trust Fund has highlighted just how much
the $1 billion a year corporation receives in revenues from
“Government Grants & Contracts”: $363.2 million in fiscal year
ending June 30, 2009—a third of PPFA’s revenues coming out of the
pockets of American taxpayers. And while Planned Parenthood tried to
argue that none of the (federal) money went towards abortions,
National Right to Life pointed out how those funds helped to keep
those facilities open and those clinicians employed, freeing up
other funds for the promotion and performance of abortion.
The Trust Fund also noted how abortions increased at Planned
Parenthood at a rate that very neatly paralleled the rate of
increase in government funding.
We laid out how local communities and states, some financing
abortion directly, and the federal government, particularly through
its Medicaid and Title X family planning programs, poured millions
of tax dollars every year into Planned Parenthood’s coffers.
And we exposed how Planned Parenthood has been taking its money
and using it to build giant new mega-clinics across the country
where it can do high volumes of abortion, manage web-cam abortion
systems at smaller satellite clinics, and coordinate lobbying and
campaign activities.
Engaged pro-lifers have known these things for some time. But in
2011, the message began to sink in among the general public.
In April 2011, the U.S. House voted 241–185 to defund PPFA and
its 102 affiliates. However, the bill was rejected by the
Democrat-controlled Senate.
That was not the end of the matter, however. In May 2011, Indiana
Governor Mitch Daniels signed a law cutting $1.4 million in Medicaid
funds from Planned Parenthood. Kansas Governor Sam Brownback signed
similar legislation in his state later that month, shifting Title X
money to full-service health clinics rather than Planned Parenthood.
Both Wisconsin and North Carolina passed bills in June stripping
Planned Parenthood of tax funding. Texas cut more than $61 million
in family planning funds and Tennessee’s governor directed the state
health commissioner to direct family planning funds to county health
departments.
Now, of course, a full federal ban will have to wait for a new
president and a new Congress, and Planned Parenthood and its allies
in the media and in the Obama Administration have come out in full
force against these defunding efforts, tying up many of them in the
courts. But the real story on Planned Parenthood is out.
People are finally beginning to ask why, especially in a time of
budget austerity, any taxpayer dollars should be funding an
organization for whom systematically killing innocent human beings
is a part of its basic business model. PPFA will continue to try to
expand, but may find it harder to get its hands on the public funds
it needs to continue growing its abortion empire.
I’d like to think that years of years of careful pro-life
research and education had something to do with that.
The flowers aren’t blossoming just yet, but I think I see a few
healthy green shoots popping up.